thats not fair i think i can make a music video of myn in that amount or i can run a music CDs Shop, thats just nonsense i recently saw a article where some government guy also had movies downloaded from torrents but no one Sue's them , Poor women
let me correct that....she didn't just download them. she was found guilty of sharing these songs with others....distributing them and thereby causing huge damages to the the copyright owners of these songs. the crime was as good as making pirated CD's of music albums. I think it's a fair judgement.
So I guss right now nobody shares those songs ofcourse they do, are they going to do something about it? I don't think so.... she was just very unlucky that she got caught. Anyway even if its a fair judgment she will never get that kind of money, and jailing her won't bring the artist money, so whats the whole point in the end? those who download don't buy.
this is to set an example. think about all the hard working musicians, producers, composers, distributors, and everyone invloved in the record industry. they make a living out of this. if you were a singer, would you want people to buy your CD or download them for free?
I think they're just making an example of her. Im sure many/most of the poeple in that courtroom will have pirated something at some time in their life. Im sure people who have been employed by the RIAA/MPAA have pirated things before. Theres no way an average woman will be able to fork out $1.9m for this. What happens if she cant pay?
Just an attempt to scare downloaders, a ridiculously high fine and story that has been heavily publicized...and she was fined for sharing those 24 songs.
WOW! Thats a ton of money for only 24 songs. I must be in some pretty deep shit if only 24 songs equals 2 million bucks!
Yeah I agree with you that was ridiculous.. I know a company exactly who has an absurd rules just like this one.. poor humans I really pity them..
i think she can buy the singer with that money instead of downloading his/her song illegally mad judge lol!
Yeah a lot of you are overlooking the point. She was guilty of the sharing part as much as the downloading part. Also, they know they're not going to get that much money which is why they keep trying to get her to settle for the original amount of $3500. So really, she has "$3500" owed if she settles.