I originally posted in another thread: http://forums.digitalpoint.com/showthread.php?t=337510 regarding 301 redirects under a windows environment from oldpage.htm to newpage.htm (oldpage has PR that I want to retain etc etc). All I got was meta-refresh answers and code that doesn't work, so I'm assuming I can't do this under windows environment (I dont have access to the control panel thingy!) I've come to the conclusion I may need to move from my hosting services windows environment to their linux system so I can use .htaccess for the redirects. What are the pros and cons of windows vs linux - anyone care to volunteer? (Apart from the fact that in linux I can use .htacess for 301's ...) Or IS there a way of doing 301's from one htm page to another under windows ...? Thanks in advance for any input
Windows is a horrible solution unless you need ASP / ASP.net. Otherwise *nix has all of the pros of windows & a whole lot more.
How is Windows a horrible solution? I've been in the webhosting industry for a very long time, in my opinion Windows has always been more stable and flexible. And that's based on 10 years of server administration experience on *NIX, Solaris, BSD & Windows platforms.
Hi Guys, and thanks for the (opposing) views My interest is mainly from a website creation, development and maintenance perspective. I have a small site hosted under windows, but maybe I should move over to my hosting services linux environment, for the reasons outlined in the first post. What difference might that make to me from a day to day perpective. Will I notice any difference in maintaining the site? Do I get more or less functionality?
In a old age, I had use a technique to solve that problem in ASP, I forget actually, need to find it in old files, but as far as I remember the method was in the first line of the page, send response status to requester (301 or 302) and redirect to newly page
I don't normally get involved in these sorts of things. If you're a web host, *nix is an ideal environment. Stable, affordable and will easily run the various standard applications out there. I would challenge the people who think otherwise, to come up with several good reasons why Linux is not a good hosting platform.
Hi Cav609, To properly answer your question, for a small site on a well managed server you will probably not notice much of a difference. Reasons I personally like Linux for hosting: - SSH access - Lots of scripting possibilities - Cron jobs - .htaccess files - Natural bias (I'm an RHCE) - Text based config files
Care to tell me otherwise using some statistics? Windows: 1. Proprietary. You rely on Microsoft for updates 2. Proprietary. You rely on Microsoft to fix (most) bugs. *nix: 1. Mmm, open source & developed by hundreds of thousands of users. Fixes arrive quickly or you can fix it yourself. 2. Mmm, rsync / scp / shell.
Hey everyone - thanks for the input - I think I might have inadvertently started a lively debate! Tandac - thanks in particular for focussing on my question, gives me some comfort in making the switch from windows. Just to stir things up a bit more - could the windows advocates tell me what I can get from windows that I cant get from *nix??
Don't use windows unless you need to run the latest .NET applications or host ASP pages. It's not a good platform for servers, just not designed for that. If you need a server you must *ALWAYS* go for Linux if you can.
Any windows advocates want to persuade me to stay with windows rather than migrate to linux? I have an open mind ...!
Ok, well no-one has extolled the virtues of windows - converted to linux a couple of weeks ago and no problems at all. htaccess has now resolved the issue for me. Thanks for all the advice guys!
Windows is like linux only with closed source (more undiscovered bugs), and unnecessary GUI overhead (takes up RAM). Windows is for games, Linux is for servers!