Who wants change in "Solicitations & Announcements"?

OK, some of you may want to jump down my throat for stating this because of the dreaded "dominoe effect" that you think it may have for all other categories, but I believe that the "Directories - Solicitations & Announcements" forum should be further split into two parts:

a. established, PR3+ directories
b. new, PR0-PR2, and/or dropped domains of any PR

I used to monitor the "Solicitations & Announcements" every day, but it's gotten to the point at which I'm absolutely fed up with having to sift through the 98% of offers that fit into "b." I'm sure Mr. DP can come up with a decent solution that will make it easier for submitters like me who are only interested in offers from established, reputable directories.

I'm interested in what directory owners think.

 

looks a good idea...I support you.

 

I would be a little torn between the two options — (a) as is, or (b) your suggestion.

• I do faithfully submit to almost all of the free directories, even the brand-new ones. (1) It helps fellow DP members, and (2) over the past couple of years a few of those new, free directories have risen like cream to the surface and have passed along a nice PR as well as some modest traffic in a few instances.

• On the other hand, it would indeed be a time-saving benefit to be able to focus on credible, established directories, paid or free, that are more likely to provide immediate benefits.

 

I also submit to new directories if they are from established directory owners. What I am proposing would not "do away" with such offers; rather, it would make it easier for you to locate them.

 

I think Japan wants change in "Solicitations & Announcements"?

But dude PR fluctuates, also if Mr DP, who is probably enjoy a nice holiday in Bahamas, does allow that, than its going to be who wants split of the category to "free, paid , and reciprocal only" subcategories.

Its an endless chain and i think Mr. DP would like to avoid starting a chain reaction.

 

I would recommend 2 section in there for:

1. Free Directories - Offering free submissions.

2. Paid Directories - Offering only complete paid submissions.

 

I don't have an issue with new directories being mixed with established directories but I have stopped submitting much because of the time spent weeding out dropped domains etc. (Generally I think the standard of new directories is better than a year ago, when they all seemed to be on phpld v2, standard template.)

It would be very useful if paid directories (not paid-for dropped domains!) had a separate section though and I support that idea.

Incidentally the problem with dropped domains is worse in 'link sales' than in 'directories'.

 

it creates way more problems then it solves

 

No, it doesn't. You can't make an assertion like that without explanation.

 

This would be a nice suggestion.

 

humm, your suggestion is better.

 

I like the idea but ultimately it is up to Shawn.

Col

 

Made me laugh a little as i cant see too many people wanting to announce their "Dropped Domain" in the correct section of the forum.

Plus i think its a little harsh to put PR0 to PR2 with so called dropped domains, its like saying that were not worthy.

Only adding to the PR obsession and creating more conflict i would imagine.

May take the community feel away and create a feeling of segregation.

 

It all sounds like a good - in theory.

If we went on the PR theme, whats to stop dropped domains (with established PRs being used) would these go in the established or new sub section?

Secondly having a free and paid section - this would provide someone to move threads on a constant basis; a large majority of directories go from free to paid in a couple of weeks; if you've even seen the vilesilencer list (or directory critic for that matter) they are constantly having to check and recheck listings to ensure the submission option hasn't changed.

What could be done however is a more conform method of title used (as on the v7 forum) - ie. DirectoryURL.com (F,R,P) - indicating free, recip or paid.

 

Offering only complete paid submissions can be kept for Paid section. It may feature bidding dirs and complete paid directories.

 

Well, it's pretty simple: if you don't place your offer in the correct category (intentionally or unintentionally), you get red reps and infractions. People tend to learn very quickly that way.

They are what they are. There's nothing wrong with making distinctions for everyone's benefit.

It has more to do with sustainability, trustworthiness, and proven track records.

Everyone has a role in a community or family.

 

Do people really still submit to directories?

 

EducationLinks, ok, will be interesting if they make that change here to the forum.