Which of these designs do you like more?

hello,

just wanted to hear the view of some dp designers here which of these
two designs you like more?

http://www.webbest-design.de

or


http://www.webbest-design.de/old

any critics and views are welcome.

thanks and regards

 

I like the first one more, but i don't like the border on the top of the navigation menu.

 

I like the second one more because you're not manipulating the background image. In the first one, your text is competing with the background image, which makes it a little difficult to read. You always want your text to be legible.

 

The old one is better, doesn't take too long to download the image,
and the fonts too...

Except that the right sidebar font is too small.
That's my thought...

 

Hi there,

I think the first one is better than the second.

Regards,
WS

 

I would also go with the old one.
I agree with water_bills.

The other one is hard to read.

good luck!

 

I don't like either design more. However, I do like the old design better.

 

I like the second one the best. There are less contrasting items in the background with the user interface.

 

I like the first one...nice on the eye...

 

thanks so far for your views, seems to be that the votes are
5:3 for the old (second) one.

Anyone else has anything to add?

 

the first one looks nice but the back ground image takes time to load.

 

The first one is better than second.. Simple and smooth

 

I think the second one.

 

I also prefer the first one.

 

now 6:6, so both designs are equal in terms of preferation.

 

I preffer the first one. I think vbulettin let you add a poll at this thread. You can try !

 

yes, now voting included, thanks for remembering

 

I like the new design more.

 

I like the new design more but that image takes a while to load :/ thats the only downfall to it

Thanks,
John

 

Best? Best is IMPOSSIBLE because there are only two to choose from.