Which is Better: Old or New?

I'm wondering which you think is better ad placement:?


Old: http://directory.proud-collector.com/a0004060/article_old.aspx

-or-

New: http://directory.proud-collector.com/a0004060/article.aspx


The article is kinda long, there is more adsense on the new page at the bottom.

Thanks

 

Old is better in my opinion because it captures your attention right at the beginning. The new one is also decent, but it depends on how interested the user is in the article, and if they will read till the end.

 

I agree, the old version catches your attention right away as opposed to having to scroll down the entire page for your ads.

 

i think you must use one ads unit at the top of the article and one ads unit at the bottom of the article . it will be greater

 

the old one is better

 

Because most all of the replies say the old page layout is better, I switched them back.