So if I got hold of an aged domain but it wasn't indexed. Would this be the same as a domain that is indexed and aged?
Wouldn't make any difference... People sometimes park domains for years and then use them again. If it's active then it will be indexed regardless of age fastreplies
I do not think so in your case. It is depends on how domain was developed and the link building toward it. The link profile and content change or update history is a key. If your website is parked and already indexed in Google. It does not mean that domain has aged and authority status. Did you ever see parked website have full sitelinks ever? If only parked content and never done on improvement such as link building, add content then that domain is not different from new registered domain.
It all depends on the history of the domain. How it was used in the past? Was it used for spamming mostly? If the domain has a clean past and it's aged, you should be able to get a nice ranking compared to starting with a new domain.
The possibility of the domain that age depends if the domain is penalized something like that. Google always indexes new sites. Try to check if your robot.txt is the one doing it. Because in my past experience my site is not index. But I don't know what happened then I check my robot.txt. And there I see the problem.