Would it be smart to have the website title in the title page along with a short blurb about the specific page, example.. X - Y = Fishing PA Network - Using the Right Bait Something thing like that or will the X part be too much and considered duplicate? Assuming X has keywords relevant to the site.
That is a common format for title tags. You can also experiment with placing the page-specific text at the front and site name at the end.
typically it is best practice to use this format for your title tags: <keyword rich title of page>-<title of website> example: <title>Washington Nationals Tickets - NatsChat.com</title>
I agree with BILZ, if you want to put your site name in the page title, better to put it at the end with keywords pertinent to the page first.