I saw a poster on this forum who said that US won the war...i guess he need to read about the latest developments. ISLAMABAD - The United States has withdrawn its troops from its four key bases in Nuristan, on the border with Pakistan, leaving the northeastern province as a safe haven for the Taliban-led insurgency to orchestrate its regional battles. The US has retained some forces in Nuristan's capital, Parun, to provide security for the governor and government facilities. The American position concerning the withdrawal is that due to winter conditions, supply arteries are choked, making it difficult to keep forces in remote areas. The US has pulled out from some areas in the past, but never from all four main bases. http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/KJ29Df04.html
I think OP is referring to the other thread where robjones was bragging about 'winning' in Afghanistan
NEWS is that United States ceded the control of province to Taliban...same happened in some districts of khost, paktia and paktika in october 2009..
I read an article in TIMES the author showed the statistics of area goverened by talibans, it was massive compared to the area under US control. Its been 10 years america is fighting over there with its 70,000+ soldiers, billions of dollars of tax payers money and money earned by selling weapons to other nations etc and yet they are unable to govern it completely, moreover no signs on Mulla Omer or Osama Bin Laden. Is it a signal or something?
Yeah thank goodness we took over Iraq and focused no resources on Bin Laden and Afghanistan. What were they thinking???
I think some of the Americans forget the reality they suffered in Vietnam, now in Iraq seems history is going to repeat itself.!!! Thumbs up for the Taliban's again, no power is going to make them down...!! Neither USSR nor USA ...!! (Don;t think that I am a supporter of Taliban, but I really appreciate what they are doing with such less resources and making Americans & their Allies to reside in Kabul only ..!! )
What do you think about that "polite"? Good or bad news? For me, anyone who throws acid in a childs face for wanting an education is a subhuman peice of shit who needs to have many holes shot in them. We can't possibly stop untill we have slaughtered every last one of these disgusting subhumans. So what do you think about a group who throw acids in childrens faces taking control of a province? Good or bad? something to oppose, or something to gloat about? How about you Postingpays? what do you think about a group who throw acid in childrens faces? Thumbs up, right? That is what you said, isn't it? Heres a wild stab in the dark, a guess, a hunch.... you both don't happen to be muslim do you? Silly question, of course you are. Nothing but belonging to the same cult could bring anyone out in support of such filthy little scumbags and thier tactics of intimidation, physical violence against children, cowardice and opression. Thumbs up to the taliban, right? You should be ashamed of yourself. But if you aren't, don't worry, the shame i feel on your behalf will make up for it.
That is so backward that it is almost unbelievable in 2009 a female can't even be allowed to be educated
why do you think it would be a bad news for me? I don't like taliban but i prefer them over US or their puppets. as for your second question...Taliban denied those attacks and schools are still open in areas under Taliban control..so i don't have a reason not to believe them.. And unlike you am living in an area which is considered under Taliban control. and this discussion is off topic..you may create another thread for justification of war .
apparently, he can't understand the simple logic that it is the Afghan People who decide that what is good for them and what isn't If the Taliban are bad, locals can throw them out, kill them and do whatever the want. USA and NATO do not need to export their version of Freedom and Liberty to other countries
I'm all for people deciding what is good for them, like getting an education without having acid thrown in their faces by subhuman barbarians. But the talibastards don't what what is good for people, they want people to do as they are told according to a primative old desert myth. So instead of defending them on the grounds that they happen to be the same religion as you try developing some integrity, some decentcy and some compassion and condemn them for the countless acts of utter barbarism that they routinely inflict on people, people who are invariably women. I'd like straight forward answers to the following questions. I know you won't give straight forward answers, and I don't really want you to, because that will demonstrate exactly how indefensible your rancid little opinions are. 1. What do you think about people who throw acid in childrens faces? 2. What do you think about people who beat women in public? 3. What do you think about people who marry and have sex with children? 4. What do you think about executing people for being gay?
The afgans. All of them though, including women. Now answer my questions. You have to ask yourself what kind of a person your cult has reduced you to when you are reluctantto condemn the beating of womb in the streets, the disfiguing of children with acid and the execution of gays just because the animals who commit these attrocities just happen to believe in the same made up shit ad you do. Good job your god doesn't exist, he would be ashamed of you.
so what the hell are us and nato doing there? when afghans felt that taliban are not good enough they could have kicked them out themselves who gives you the right to call for genocide ? who allowed this WE to take care of the whole world ? is this some sort of global bully ? labeling others subhuman, only because they don't agree with your version of life? I can't answer your questions in yes/no , unfortunately you only understand the language of 2+2=4, anything more complex just files off your head
Yeah i'm sure women standing up for thier rights wont result in yet another beating in the street. Well "we" seem to be the only ones with moral fibre, so "we" have to step in and right wrongs. maybe if those living in dust bowls weren't such savages "we" wouldn't have to keep giving them a slap and correcting them. labeling them subhuman because they throw acid in childrens faces and beat women in the street for not dressing the way they have been told to dress. Are you sure you can't answer because of your cowardice? Go on, grow a pair and answer the simple questions i put directly to you. hey, remember when i said i hope you don't answer because that will demonstrate exactly how indefensible your rancid little opinions are? I love how predictably inept the religious are.
Here comes the world best morally fibred people. I don;t think I have to show you the reality?? What you have been doing in Iraq and Afghanistan killing thousands of innocents? Still morally fibred? Israelites, brutally killing many of the people and most of the members of this forum agree upon their brutal activities (I know its Israel but it have your backing) Still think Morally fibred? Many of the gang rapes in Iraq, many of the detainees died of your brutal punishment, and world most known guantanamo bays brutal acts, stll saying you are morally fibred? Ohh, come on ..... Old coward behaviour..!! First, you morally fibred people have to correct your language, it highly unethical. But lets come to the point. Our God is never like yours to get crucified and the followers again supporting those who crucified them...!! Ask your priests .. !! First, Don't speak if you are not confirmed of a reality. If you say something against anybody, you must be having a proof about that. (I know your Holy You Tube is always supporting your remarks by fake videos, but still ... ) Now coming to your questions..!! 1. The people who throw acid on child faces, doesn't matter what they do. Its not allowed in Islam, and the person / group practising it are not Muslims. (Talibans always condemn that) 2. Islam never allows a women's disrespect, and the person who is doing such are not on the right path. God help them to rectify their believes. (The video was proven fake and it was not the Taliban's but those who are trying to make their bad image in the society) 3. I think, I don't have to open your old testament to prove you about the realities of sexual assaults by your so called prophets. But in Islam, its never permitted and there is not a single prove against Taliban's. If you have something, show us and it will be openly condemned. 4. 100% right, we never allow anyone being a Gay and its never allowed in our religion. For you, you have to open your own Holy Books and see that its allowed or not.. (Hope I am not forgetting that most of you have no interest with religion or God.) I think I have replied to your query, and I am not a believer of your HOLY YOU TUBE, I believe i facts not words like you ..!!
Yet again, the muslims find it hard to condemn acts of utter barbarism and instead opt for the routine of defending thier religion, and frighteningly enough, the murderous scumbag bastards we have come to know as the taliban. I love how easy it is to get you guys to expose the poisonous, rancid mindset that your little religion has inflicted on you. It's like you aren't even trying to hide the fact that islam is a murderous death cult based around the rantings of a child rapist any more. If something horrific is done in the name of your religion, you defend your religion. If something horrific is done by someone of the same religion, defend your religion. Why do you find it so difficult to condemn unreservedly the beating of women publicly, the throwing of acid in the faces of children and the executions of gays? Of course, we already know the answer, it's because you support them fully on the grounds that these horrific acts happen to be commited by someone who believes in the same made up bullshit as you.
First read my replies to your questions then make a statement. I know you are reading with closed eyes as its coming in favour of real Islam. Never mind ..!!
Your replies are the usual typical bullshit. waa waa they aren't muslims, waa waa thats not islam, waa waa i care more about defending my religion and its members than i do children who have acid thrown in thier faces.