What do you think will be the better link and why 1) Front page only 2) Sitewide including the front page
i would not suggest on having sitewide links. they dont work the way they used to. few years back, i was able to get a site ranked high with few sitewide links from large sites with thousands of pages, dont work like that anymore as google knows by now what sitewide links are. i would go for frontpage links which will look lot more natural