I posted my site here (and elsewhere) for review a while ago. A lot of the feedback helped me greatly improve my site, so I thought I would try and get some feedback once more to make it even better. http://supersmashbc.com
OK. Here's my honest opinion. Good overall website. I can see where you're headed and you're almost there. The static background choice is fantastic and it has grown on me. 1) Work on the logo. The "Super Smash BC" logo could be better. I suggest you find the fonts used for the original logo, and create a subheading based on those fonts. 2) Remove the Random Member mod. It's pointless and takes up valuable space. 3) Add Forum, Members, Team, FAQ to the Top Menu Bar. There is valuable space which is completely empty. Utilize it. 4) Move "Link to Us" under the "Donation" panel. Once you remove the random member mod and make this move, both panel sides will be even. Psychologically, the viewer will see this as cleaner in the abstract state of mind. Good Luck.
Ok, thank you for your suggestions. One thing I will say is that all of those things you said in number 3 are already up there. And the reason you see blank space is because you aren't logged in. There are other things up there (such as control panel and messages) that guests obviously can't see. I will consider the others though.