Its good has it has some 16000+ members. But you didnt monetize it well. If all the members were real people then this site could be the first among the niche.
Thats the problem. I would say 95% are real, unique, 1 account people. The problem is, it is so hard to make money with my user base for some reason. And development costs are SO EXPENSIVE Any suggestions on how to make more money with it?
Try some affiliate programs like CJ and clickbank for few days. If that dosen't work go for adsense for a month. Then choose the one that suits you much. If you wish I can partner be a partner and develop the monetization part of your site. If you are interested PM me.
Real nice site! I would try to find affiliate programs relating to your site that your comfortable promoting - (Game rentals /Downloads, blockbuster ect...)
Nice clean design, however I think all of your elements look seperated. Add a background color for your header area to connect the search option and logo graphic together.