Awesome freebies site!! Very well organized. Easy navigation. Excellent size product images. Great FAQ page. Cool Houseparty promo. Fun to scan!
I'm sorry but I do not like tables in your site, they do not look too attractive to me, specially the one at the left sidebar.
In my opinion, you need to make the template wider to take up the full screen. It looks too clustered with the 3 columns so close to each other. I also don't like the little tables around freebie stuff. Wait, I just realized that you have 4 columns. Why not combine the middle 2 like you do at the bottom. The freebies at the bottom that take up the 2 columns look waaay more attracting to me than the ones at the top.
The reason I have them tables there is because I have way to many categories so I thought I'd make that menu in the middle to make it easier for people to navigate. It's the only way I could thing of without having a major long list of categories. I might try to work a new way to do this. I do want to make the template wider but was told if I did it would break the theme design I'm going to try mess with it soon see if I can improve some of the points you guys made. I really appreciate the advice.