too many graphics and texts for the logo .They dont look like as a logo . Red one looks good (like drawing )
I'd have to agree - logo designs should only contain conventional resizeable paths. Not only because this allows them to be scaled, but also because most raster images just don't appeal as logo designs because they don't stand out. Also, the proportions aren't quite right. According to a top logo designs (whom I can't remember the name) you're supposed to have logos which fit the dimensions of 1 unit high, and 2 1/4 units across, because this is the same as the viewing range of your eye (the same reason for widescreen monitors and TVs). You may also want to reconsider the relation of the text and whatever graphic you use. Right now, the graphic completely overwhelms the typeface, and so if you ever resize it, you're going to encounter problems. Thanks.
Good graphics nd some concepts involved...the fonts used in 1st design seem irrelevant... More Practice required...find inspiration from experienced..
The blue one needs a more expressive picture. It's too common and the picture doesn't say anything about the "lost art of thinking." The red one could be improved by enlarging the whole design. It seems that the red background takes so much space in the design.
I really like the second one but the first would be better if the punch line was in line with the bottom of the man. I would give the first one 7 and the second one 9