Portable Music player or Mobile phone ?

I want honest opinion about music player..

What do you think is better ?

A separate music player like ipod. (or which one ? )
OR

A mobile phone with music features ? (if yes, which one)

Thanks. Please vote too.

 

I tend to find a separate music player better. Although phones are good to play music out loud.

 

mate, i personally can't wait for the iphone to come out in australia. i think it boasts a wonderful music player with fantastic phone capabilities.

 

I like the ipod but son prefers the phone.

 

I prefer a phone with good music quality. Getting a separate music player is out of the question for me since it will be too bulky to carry around.

 

Has anybody tested iphone ? Hows that in terms of music ?

Can anybody give me their genuine advice on "Which is the best Music phone?" ?

 

I’ll go for ipod, I’m used to it, and I prefer it.

 

I'd love to have an iPhone, but there is no way that I would spend that kind of money on a phone. So until then, it's my iPod and my cell phone - separately...

 

Personally I just have a cheap phone, and an iPod for my music. I don't like the way the iPhone is stuck on one provider, but even if it weren't I'd probably just stick with my iPod.

 

I have a t-mobile wing. mp3 player, video player, microsoft office, outlook. it uses an sd card so I have unlimited storage.

 

Thanks for your opinion guys/gals..

I think i should go for ipod too and keep my oldie mobile.