In my opinion, your site looks like you haven't decided what it is. I think it needs some graphics that illustrate that it is a movie site. Also, the URL may need changing to reflect this also. The welcome screen doesn't need to mention the history of the URL - instead it should promote the movies that can be watched for free. I suugest that you need to clarify what the purpose is for your site. Is it a hobby site or do you intend to make money from it? At the moment, it looks like a hobby site (which may be your intention). However, if it is to make money, I am not sure how you will achieve that with the site in its current format. Hope this helps.
Your content is way out of date. Your [NEW] tags are for things that are most definately not new. It appears as if you abandoned the site.
I would definately change the title. It does not look like a movie site what so ever, and if you hadn't explained on here, I would have never known. The links on the left (years), maybe try making those into categories, ie: horror, comedy...so on. I think right away people would better recognize that it's a movie site. Good luck.