The template, the page layout, and the color scheme is good, I think the site looks professional however, I do not like the logo, I think you should get a more professional logo.
Yeah, the logo is bad. And u might want to delete the fairy with the wing in top right of the template, also the font needs to be brighter, IMO
Hmmm, it looks like your using a gaming template.. not meaning sports games. I'd just switch out the template and then all will be good.
Well, I really have very little money now so I can not afford a good logo, so I made a temporary one myself.
You should be using a theme which compliments you site topics. You should include some sports images in the design. I also think the forum titles don't contrast enough with the background, they should stand out more.