Please review my 3D Logo

Hello guys,

I just converted a 2D logo into 3D and want you feedback.
by the way Qi Stand for Quality Interiors

2D Logo:



3D Logo with different angles. Please suggest one of them.
1.

2.

3.



Your comments, suggestions even criticism will be highly appreciated.

Thank you

 

Hope this is not bump. I am not allowed to put more than 4 images in one post.

4.

5.

 

why dont you stick with simple 2D it looks the best xD !! if you still need opinion on 3d's then 4. i guess..

 

i want to purchase it.
what would be its price,,,,

 

I personally think 3 and 4 are the coolest! It's a great design and I think you did well by going 3-d! Congrats!

 

its not for sale brother. its a company logo which im making for this site.. www.qi.com.pk

Well Thanks bfairo for ur opinion..

 

The third one would be my choice.
Quite nice Raq

 

I really like the second logo. The colors match and make it look like a real 3D image.

 

The second logo is cool and it impressed me a lot than others.

 

2nd and 4th are good .
Can i ask what software you are using ?

 

Thanks guys... still looking more reviews..

Software is 3ds MAX..

 

The 2D logo is pretty good. But the one you pick really depends on what your website looks like. Is your website very web 2.0 with high end graphics?

 

thats a simple website www.qi.com.pk and it wont have any 3d type stuff but we'll upload real interiors photos (office,home etc.) but that 2d logo looks good on website but not on company's pad, documents etc.
if u visit this www.qi.com.pk and u think there are something should modify according to ur experience then i'll appreciate that if u write.. i'll try to discuss with my website designer..
Thank you!

 

3d can be quire difficult to pull off. You seem to have done OK but personally prefer the 2D version.

 

2D logo is better becuase it's simpler.

 

I like 1,2 and 4

 

i will go for 2 or 3...
Btw frankly speaking i will go for 2D one because it's more appealing thn all the ones you made. I am not criticising on your design at all, your design is for sure good but sometimes you just need to go for a simpler one without any changes
Thanks alot
PHYza

 

After looking your logos,
I like the 1st one i.e. 2D logo.

But 3D logos are not upto the standard they could have been better.

Finally I'd say stick to your 2d one or look for some other 3d styles but not those you have posted.
Thanks.

 

i like 2nd one its nice

 

The 2nd one has a little light effect but

its not enough to make a 3d appearance.