6/10 I'd say. The things I noticed are: The text colour and bg colour contrast is too low. Why is Forum above Affiliate Networks? Is it part of the main nav? What is the "Type Hit Enter" box for? What do I type? Why would I want to? Where will it lead me? You need some breathing space between the bottom of the ad and the top of the Categories and between the monthly calendar and the box above (which has no heading in it). I'd also add some breathing space around the ad itself in its box. Your RSS feed icon flickers-bad for accessibility The overall look and feel is cool.