Please Help me pick a new design

I am considering redesigning my entire site. But before I do would like some feed back.

here is my current site: http://www.thunderfap.com/

Here are the designs im considering.

http://www.thunderfap.com/test/test1.htm
http://www.thunderfap.com/test/test2.htm
http://www.thunderfap.com/test/test5.htm
http://www.thunderfap.com/test/test6.htm

I know the logo needs to be reworked and I'm going to incorporate images more but first I need to pick just a rough layout. Please let me know which of these you like best and what you guys think should be changed (other than needing more images).

thanks

 

honestly? I hate them all! your current site looks better than those designs.

 

I would go with test1, but the logo definitely needs to be changed.

 

I know the logo needs to be changed but I don't have the software needed to make my own. All I have is paint and thats it. Does anyone know of any good free online tool that I could use. Either that or I pay a company to design one.

 

leave your site as it is, or get a better template than those, the green makes it look crap,

 

I agree with thos who say keep your site as it is now. It looks fine.

 

thanks for all feedback. What do you guys think about my content? The main focus of my site is meant to be the daily giveaways section where every day I add a new list of truly free stuff.

 

those templates imo don't look good.

 

I think the original is the best one. Start a logo contest here, there's alot of talent and cheap!

 

Well the old one is better than all new ones

But really man you should work on better design ! This one ... well it just looks like it is from 94

 

Sorry, but me to .

 

Test1 is better due to the standard colors.

Personally, I would start over with the design of this site.

 

lol test1 is better then remaning but they dont have proff look