What do you think that worth more.. One way link from page with lots of outbound links (example 20) or reciprocal link ?? Both pages are theme relevant .. There are some thoughts that reciprocal links worth less and less every day. Because google knows that links are exchanged and he thinks those link are exchanged for managing serps. What do you think about that ?
A good quality, on topic reciprocal link is still worth more than a poor quality one way link IMO. A good link building campaign will have a balance between one way and reciprocal links.
I know that one way link is better them reception link, but for google this link must be relevant to count.