Old page or new?

The new page converts better and for the most part is finalized, but in terms of aesthetics, content, and overall "feel", which page do you like better and why? If you like the old one, which part(s) do you like better?

OLD: http://dollarhauler.com/Zarchive/index.php
NEW: http://dollarhauler.com/index.php

I'm not looking for traffic, I want experienced, webmaster feedback.

EDIT: sorry the old one is a little tweaked up at the top. Ignore that and just pretend it is OK - the new version uses a different way to organize the images on the header.

 

No one has any advice?

 

Looks quite similar. The new look may be better, but why not redesign? It's too dark.

 

The layout is the same, just the actual content / "feel" of the page is drastically different.

Glad to hear the positive feedback so far.

What is wrong with the layout / color scheme?

 

i think your new site is better b=coz more efective,user frindly anda not fibre as the old your site anda neat

 

i think old page is better because its already in on SERP

 

First page looks much better, each column places separately

 

The new design is way better.

 

i like the new one a lot, it flows more and is more inviting.

 

I like the new one better.

Dee