I keep seeing everyone worried to be penalized by Google to the extent of even submitting their site to a high quality paid directory due to the fact that they paid for it. Submitting to relevant high quality paid directories will not hurt you, it is websites that sell any type of unrelated links that will be useless. Something else that we have to keep in mind is that Google will not penalize your site. If anything what they will do is remove the ability of the site selling the link to be able to flow pagerank. Here is what Matt Cutts from Google had to say about this. Notice the type of websites that he talks about on his blog. : http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/how-to-report-paid-links/ (Copy and Paste this link into your browser since I don't have the required 10 post to make this a live link) From reading this I don't think that a well kept directory falls into the category of these type of sites.
http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/how-to-report-paid-links/ You are correct...the paid link post by matt cutts has been blown out of proportion by a lot of people
While a "well kept" directory is unlikely to harm you, if you are buying the link for PR it is still a waste of money, IMO. Some of the large, popular directories send a fair number of visitors, and that should be your goal. /*tom*/