I just got a letter in the mail, asking me to put my credit card details and send it back to renew my domains.. but it only has 4 domains in there (all that I used to have proxies on) and the charge is $40 to renew one domain for a year. Is this some kind of scam? Cause it costs ~$8 to renew on the site.
I get those all the time. It's a scam. They are not from NameCheap or your registrar. It's from Liberty Names or DROA or some other registrar trying trick you into transfering your domains with them.