I'm sorry, I sure find myself making a lot of topics here. I'm quite the ambitious fellow you see. Here's some back story: My 'One Piece' site (sig) back in 08 ranked 1st on Google for a long time and had a PR of 5. This site has been up since 06. I was completely uninterested in the site, the site had lots of server and hacking issues, I lacked SEO skills, and during the time I had some major life issues going on so I gave in and turned the site off until further notice. I put a splash page up for almost a year where the site still ranked 1st on Google. Eventually, I stopped paying out for the server and the site went down completely for about 4 months in which time the site's PR fell to 0, it fell off Google, and I had to essentially start at ground zero again. Around November 09 I decided to put the site back up since I then had the time and skills necessary to do so. The site crawled up to 11th spot on Google within two months, and a month later it went up to the 8th spot where it's been stuck at since February or so. Although I haven't built ANY links whatsoever, the site has a PR of 2 and it's stuck there even though the site has 17k links according to Yahoo and 190,000 according to Google Webmaster Tools. 1 1/2 months ago I went link building crazy and I nabbed a TON of nice dofollow links ranging from PR 2-5.. I got at least 20 links like that, I did several link exchanges, and gathered a few hundred other relevant PR 0 links, plus I got a ton of links naturally from being exposed. I've been desperately waiting for the PR update because I think it'll be a doozy but my search engine rank hasn't budged and I saw a competitor just go from spot 5 to 1st on Google, beating even wikipedia. My site: onepiecehq.com Competing site: watch-onepiece.com What I don't get is they have literally a quarter of the link backs I have, they have only 1 PR higher than me but they're beating PR 4-5 links, their SEO isn't any better than mine from what I see, they've only been online for a little over a year, their site has way less content, and they have nothing over my site other than 1 pr which might change during the next pr update. I don't understand why this site is kicking my ass so bad and why Google is strictly keeping me at spot 8. Maybe I'm yet to reap the rewards for my work, but it's really frustrating putting all this work out, staying the same, while watching minor sites over rank me with little effort. What am I doing wrong here? Can somebody please help me out?
PR is not the be all and end all now adays. I have a cool little PR addon for firefox so whenever I search on Google each result has it's PR shown, I often see PR1-2 out ranking many 4-5 and sometimes 6. The Google algorithm is something which is always changing, they often sandbox websites for minor infractions and you may have been slapped with penalty for your website going down. Try and think of any other changes you may have made, maybe a change in your keywords? As for the other site having less links, many preach you need 'tons of backlinks' but I prefer quality over quantity when link building. 20 back links from websites with PR ranging from 2-5 is a start but nothing more, build more and do a abit of keyword research to target other top spots incase you cannot reclaim the top spot for your domain name keyword. Hope this has helped.
SEO has changed quite a bit over the years. You usually cannot look at individual factors and come up with an easy answer. What keyword are you searching for? I noticed the words "One Piece" a hell of a lot on your site. An example is
Thing is, since I didn't build most of my links, most of my links are from relevant sites interested in my content. I think I should at least have almost as much if not more relevant links than my competitor. I can't think of one single thing that site excels at. I did make a few changes a while back ago, but the site's updated 2-3 times a week since as long as I've had it and it's never affected my rank before. My competitor adds a new link twice a week, but they don't change their page at all so that may be one reason their beating me but I doubt something that small could make such a huge difference. It's been a year since the downtime, so I don't know why Google would still be penalizing me. It doesn't make any sense. @CANADIANeH My keyword is 'one piece'. I used to have the word one piece on there a lot more, but I removed a few... it didn't seem to impact my rankings at all.
dont look only on PR... PR5 with 50 outbound links is nothing better than a clean PR1 page with few links... also, go to quality not quantity... one thing that may cause this problem is anchor text... your domain is keyword friendly but if you have 99% of anchor text sound like "one piece", than that's not good...