Public rep giving has become a joke at SEO chat. Its stupid w/people clamoring for rep. Keep it anonymous.
Yeah I don't have a problem with the way it is... My sig withstanding, I would offer a word of advice.. Don't talk about it.. don't ask in threads why someone gave you bad rep.. the only thing that is going to do is encourage others to bad rep you as well. Sure you might get someone who comes by and tries to balance things out, but the net sum is you are going to lose rep because you post a follow up in a thread not about rep asking why someone gave you bad rep. Personally I want to know why wrote my sig comment, so I can give them a green rep. I think it is funny. Even if they did give me red rep.
The only dumb thing about the rep system is this..... Last I checked, WAY more than 10 members a day make high quality posts. Right??!! How about uping that to 20. *hint*