As i stated above i had people who did not want to submit there banner to the thread "why i don't know" so they submitted it to me VIA PM. So i contacted the winner and/or winners VIA PM. And i left it up to them to post that they won.
This is comming off a bit strange. Could you please just post who the winners where so we know that you are not using our ads without paying?
Excuse me coming off strange? Aren't you one of the ones who did not want to post you banner in the thread after i asked you to so i could keep this whole thing public? As for using someones banner without paying for it i would never stoop that low to even think of doing something like that. If everyone that submitted a banner wants to make them public then i will state who the winner and/or winners were. I don't know what is so strange about this i am not the one who wanted to do any of this privately.
No your wronge...again. I wanted to keep my entry private untill the contest was over as to not have others steal my ideas which is fine to do. What your doing is refusing to post the winner which suggests that you did not pick one and are just using the ads without paying. I dont see why you dont just say who won the competition. Why would they NOT want to be congratulated? ...strange
I will confirm that my entry was selected and payment was quickly received from the CH. We also revised the animation slightly from the one posted on this thread here: The revised banner has also been posted on the CH's website.
Anyway, All entries should be public, some CH's make that as a rule and I think it's the best and fair procedure.