Let's find out the relative success of different SEO business models

Discussion in 'Search Engine Optimization' started by stellar1, Jan 22, 2011.

  1. #1
    I'm just getting into SEO, although I've dabbled on the internet business scene (more like observed it actually) for a few years now.

    Now I want to get into SEO in depth and make a business of it.

    I've heard of the different revenue models, which I understand are:
    1. adsense (lots of low-investment info sites?)
    2. lead generation
    3. paid content (membership sites, e-books, paid video, etc)
    4. affiliate linking (high-investment info site; perhaps blogging based)
    5. (what else am I missing?)

    I am curious what people's experiences and general impressions are of the different models:
    • what you like and don't like
    • pain in the a** factor for your particular model
    • fun factor for your chosen model (and others)
    • your impression of the relative ROI (return on investment) for your particular model
    • etc.

    If you have tried different models, then your viewpoint is perhaps even more interesting because you can compare them.

    Hopefully this turns into a good discussion!
     
    stellar1, Jan 22, 2011 IP
  2. DanAbbamont

    DanAbbamont Guest

    Messages:
    330
    Likes Received:
    7
    Best Answers:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    0
    #2
    This is actually a pretty good idea for a thread. Be happy to contribute.

    AdSense
    I actually like this one and if I were to do my own web projects (instead of consulting) these days, it would probably have something to do with AdSense. The advantage here is that it works with such a wide variety of content on any topic you can dream up. It's great to start and test projects with because you can worry about content and promotion and leave finding advertisers to an algorithm. If you find one specific project is generating a lot of traffic you can always set aside some time to monetize it in a more creative manner. This way you're not at risk for wasting time up front.

    Lead Generation
    I really like lead generation with paid traffic. You can collect all the data you need, split test and tweak, etc. With SEO there are a few challenges. First, who wants to link to a lead generation site? They're almost always thin and they've got no reason not to be. Also, you don't get the data you do with PPC so split testing ad copy and things like that becomes impossible. Even if you get the traffic, you just can't fine tune it as well.

    Paid Content
    This works, but I'm kind of skeptical of it. You're more often than not marketing to the least savvy audience by selling them info that is either nonsense or could have been found for free. There's nothing wrong with it really, you're just in bad company if you do it.

    Affiliate Programs
    There are some challenges surrounding these as well. You put all this effort into trying to sell one thing with no guarantee of payment. At least with consulting you're getting paid hourly. If you are trying to SEO a site that's meant to sell an affiliate product, you are probably going to face a lot of competition from people in the same boat. It's also hard to get really good links to those sites. Just like the lead gen, who wants to link to those? This is why when you look up a niche that is known for having popular affiliate programs, it looks like a contest to see who can spam better.


    IMO the best place to end up is consulting in a niche that's competitive but has room for real creativity. I was only able to get to that point because I had my own successful projects though.
     
    DanAbbamont, Jan 25, 2011 IP
  3. stellar1

    stellar1 Greenhorn

    Messages:
    41
    Likes Received:
    0
    Best Answers:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    #3
    Thanks for the insight. I get such conflicting information it's a little confusing. I took a look at your blog and found some great stuff and it makes a lot of sense. I am going to keep investigating and blaze a path that works well for me.
     
    stellar1, Jan 31, 2011 IP