I'm researching some sites which ranking very well. May main research purpose is the site authority building. We know link popularity is the main factor for authoriy site, But i have a question about the relationship between amount of backlins and amount of backlink websites. I recently found two sites, Site A have 200K backlinks, Site B have 100K backlinks, they have the same PR4 on the home page, but one of site B's product review page ranked better than site A. I have found their pages almost same seo factors, only the site's backlinks amount is different, also a lot of site B's product page ranked better than site A. I found site B have about 600 backlink sites which generated 100K backlinks, Site A have about 400 backlink sites. Does that means more backlink sites is better than more backlinks amount from less backlink sites for authority site building? How do you think about it?
In theory, you want more "unique" sites linking to your web pages. You don't just multiple backlinks from the same site, even though it does provide value your better off with multiple sites linking to you rather than a site with multiple links too you.
There are so many other factors involved here. I think you are probably asking the wrong question. Sure, having a website with 500k definately helps pass value to your other internal pages, but to compare 2 sites purely on the number of backlinks and onsite optimisation overlooks a huge determining factor. TARGETED page links. I have seen sites with just 12 total backlinks rank first on Google beating a site with 70,900 total backlinks. This isn't an anonmoly either, I've seen plenty of similar situations. Clearly sheer numbers of backlinks are not the most important thing. Even when the backlinks are not spammy and oniste optimisation is up to scratch for both sites, you'll still find many examples of sites with just a few backlinks ranking higher than sites with tonnes of backlinks. The question is how come? It can be a number of things, but in most of my time working as an SEO I have found the major difference between the site with just a few links and the one with lots is that the site with less links normally has more of its backlinks containing the targeted keywords in the anchor text. Oh and btw - although there really isn't a straight forward answer to your question (because it overlooks so many other factors), assuming all other factors equal. A site with backlinks from many unique domains will pull more value than one with many backlinks from a smaller cluster of unique domains.