Noitartst.com is my blog, and I'm trying to figure out a decent theme for it, but I simply don't know. I really need one because my blog, as you can see, my blog looks less than professional. I've been searching for themes at: mythemeshop.com but I'm not wedded to it. I just want to make it as easy and accessible to guests as is realistically possible. So you know, my blog, in all technicality, is: noitartst.com
I don't see your previous theme, but the current one is still less professional by my standard. You should build a custom theme to make your site stand out. If you can't do it yourself, hire someone.
Try some at themeforest or somewhere else, it won't cost much. and get rid of that SEO plugin that find its way to display itself at the footer. you don't really need this, your content is king, try to put keyword in your content but not too much, google will finally index it, and good luck