hey if "you" (whoever you accosiate yourself with) have defeated Israel back then, Israel wouldn't exist today (because thats was the aim of the arab countries in attacking Israel), so its kinda hard to argue don't you think
yeah, and due to Israel defeating Egypt and Syria, the napalm in the canal didn't fire at Egyptians (disabled) and Egyptians crossed the canal into the east bank killing Israelis like flies you need to read the diaries of the Israeli forces commanders at that time also have your eye sticking on This article - it's on a .us domain
just Google "october 1973" and see the REAL facts BBC UK News - Read and Listen and watch and btw, it was 10th of Ramadan, the month where all muslims fast from dawn to sunset - but we did it to victory though
Ba7ebahaaa : War is usually going on because of territory is that right ? Since Arab countries were attacking to conquer land and since they did not that means Israel successfully defended its territory that means they won Sure there were huge losses on Israeli side but only because they were caught unprepared. In two days they gathered their forces and destroyed Syrian and Egyptian forces. Syrians were especially suffering some serious damage. Also let me remind you that Egypt recognized Israel as a country in its borders so that means Israel won for sure.... Yom Kipur war was not going on just 2 days when joint Syrian and Egyptian forces were kind of "winning". What happened later I think you know
Stupid argument ... what 10th of Ramadan ? Egyptians especially were preparing for war for over 2 years so that argument that it was Ramadan is kind of weak don't you think ?
Man, you are twisting the facts here the war was in our land (Sinai) which Israel occupied and now it belongs to us the war of 1973 was in Egypt not Israel the war field was Suez canal which is ours since it was dug now our land is back to us and 1 month ago we celebrated the 33th liberty day since 1973 we celebrate 6 Oct 1973 (Egyptian national holiday) while Israel don't do we celebrate a day we were defeated ?
it was a "peace for land" program, so Israel returned Sinai to Egypt in 1979 and they signed a peace treaty you didn't have to go to war to get it back, you could have just asked heh btw I was in both Eilat and Sinai crossing the border from both sides, couple years ago and I could say the situation is rather peaceful there
ok now Israel is giving out land for free ? give me your house for free then or give Jerusalem to Palestinians
just the read the original text of the treaty, you'll understand.. http://www.mfa.gov.eg/MFA_Portal/en...ypt+and+the+State+of+Israel+26+March+1979.htm
http://www.asfory.com/egypt_holidays_calendar.html#Armedforcesday Armies celebrate days of their victory not days where they were defeated
heh obviously, no one admits they lost a battle. Both Israel and Hezb proclaimed their victory as well, so what? who cares
I don't need to read any treaties man, i'm happy in my country enjoying my free land i go to Sinai and enjoy the fascinating red sea there, why care about reading treaties ? first you was discussing if Egypt defeated Israel or Israel defeated Egypt now after you are proven wrong , you are talking about giving out land for peace and treaties ? what's after ? just put "October 1973" as search string in Google (don't write anything about Israel and Egypt" then see the results talking about Victory of the Egyptians taking back their own land Google isn't Egyptian, is it ? I think this discussion is over and won't get anything new
This will bring such results because only arabs call this war "October 1973", and just to remind you Egypt didn't win their land back in that war. The entire Sinai peninsula stayed in Israeli control after that war. How being pushed back beyond the Suez canal, Israeli troops crossing it and loosing the entire air force be considered a victory? Seems like you listen to too much propaganda.
You are twisting the facts! In 1973 it was in israel - do you know why? Because they won the war in 1967 and conquer sinai, so in 1973, the war was in Israel (It's like you will say that the golan is syria's land now). Suez canal is and was egyptian land, that's only prove how much you lost the war ... In 1979 there was "peace for land" program like goldman said and sinai was given back to egypt, just because of peace actions. But you are egyptian and your pride is talking ...