Is blog commenting a Spamming

its totally depends on you.

 

Hi,

I don't think all blog commenting would be calculated as spamming if your comments are niche relative and add values to blogs. This is the reason why blog commenting is still a popular back linking channel these day. Also, interactive would be the soul of any blogs, IMO.

all the best,

 

According to me, blog commenting is not spamming if u put a relevant link on relevant page according to your keyword.But considering that u r not using irrelevant comments content for posting your comment,which effects the content of the page.Because Search engine may consider the comments as content of that page.

 

it all depends on the blog commenter i'd assume. if the blog commenter goes from blog to blog, barely reading the article(s) and commenting, then that would be considered spam. but if the blog commenter goes from blog to blog, offering insight and comments of value, then that seems morally correct.

it's a bit of a gray area if you ask me.

 

diversity of domain link good for ranking. than post comment on different different domain website.




Computer Repair Troubleshooting

 

if you do intentionally for link building,Yes It is...

 

Blog commenting is not spam until unless you are not using it just for backlink. Usually people remove those links where the visitors have used there keywords instead of there names, but I do not consider every comment spam. If the visitors have added some useful information in their comment then I approve them.

 

Blog commenting is not spam if you give a right comments related to article or post. If you are commenting on blog with keyword and putting url on it so some blog report it as a spam.

 

Blog commenting is not spamming.if the comment is unique it can't be spam !

 

Not all blog comments are spamming. Good blog comment is combination of informative information and relevant links.

 

BLOG Commenting is not Spam.. A lot blogger used "noFollow" tag to discourage SEO spamming.

 

If you are doing genuine blog commenting, like you are posting a comment according to blog post than i think it is not spamming.

 

Blog commenting will not be a spam, But if we do comment on irrelevant blog with unwanted msg then it will be considered as a spam.

 

Of course, genuine blog commenting is not spamming, and is exactly what networking is all about.

Spamming using Scrapebox for example, which we are specialists at btw, is one of the most powerful backlink building methods available, and a sure fire way to promote your off site optimisation in your SEO endeavours. Of course, technically it is spamming, however, with well spun, relevant commenting, it can still offer good quality genuine content to the original bloggers blog.

 

but most of the sites ban you if you do blog commenting for spaming

 

Not at all. It's down to your skill level in how you perform the mass commenting. If you spamming with tons of generic C**p spammy links, sure, you will be deleted and the post won't stick. If you're clever, you get great success. This is how you see some site flying in their backlinks. It's not done manually TRUST me!

Listen, if you're doing a mass commenting run, expect 50% comments to stick for a good ratio. So if you're blasting out 20 000 links, expect 10 000 links to stick that run.

 

Obviously, using scrapebox or xrumer is the best way to spam blogs and forum.
Actually, I think this thread is a waste of time.
Everybody knows what a blog comment should be without to be spammy:

For example:

"I liked your idea about the new ABC snowmobile. I have myself used it before and got the new 2012 model... blah blah blah"
versus
"Need a bigger d*ck? Check www.viagra1.com, www.viagra2.com and www.viagra3.com"

Anyone see a difference?

 

LOL, no I see they are the same....just kidding. Yeah, this is a good example. I agree there are some newbies on here though that need education, and the thread is not useless to beginners. People should avoid spammy blog posting and work on quality, well thought out, spun, crafted comments using a auto submission piece of software like Scrapebox.

 

Generally no, but unfortunatly now there are so many people or companys offering blog commenting or forum posting as an SEO service and most, not all just post pointless comments/posts just to get a link up with no regard to the quality of the post. There are programs that even help them spam the world with pointless annoying comments and posts leaving admin a hudge job having to clean out the junk they leave behind.

If you are posting comments or posts worth posting then no its not spam at all, I use blogs and have left blog comments with links in the past, but have never just gone round spamming like I see all so often. Same with forums I use loads of them and also have links in sigs where its ok to do so but have never posted pointless or non relevant posts just to get inbound links, pointless waste of time and annoying for all other internet users to have to put up with it.

 

In my view its not a spam, because your comments approval is depend on blog owner. If he think your comments give some good effect for its blog, then he give approval to your comment other wise its disallow your comment.