first one is better for me..but you should try to change fonts on the footer section(member's option etc...)
OW! my eyes. Somebody's a windows user! amirite? amirite? Wow, I forgot how eye-numbingly bad windows renders fonts until I saw this image. Ouch, Been using Mac and Linux for 8 years now and I just haven't seen jaggies on vector shapes in almost a decade. Do the fonts have anti-aliasing in firefox on windows or is this nastiness unavoidable?
I like the first one personally, but it does look like it's missing something. Try adding some vector shapes around your site name?
I like the colors of the second one but I don't like the border around the central area. It doesn't go well with the "grunge-like" tear at the bottom of the page. I would also add the gold text color to the headers at the bottom to make them stand out from the rest of the content.