How would you rate this Photoshop job?

Bat Terrier . On a scale of one to ten how would you rate with 10 being good.

 

I'd give it an 8. The transition from bat to dog is pretty good (love the fur that grows around the bat arm bones), and you did a nice job with the shadow cast on the ground.

My only complaint would be the light source. You can see it hitting the dog from the right on his leg and it's further emphasized with the shadow that you cast on the ground. With that in mind, the wing on the righthand side of the image should probably have a bit more light hitting it than the wing on the lefthand side of the image, which is behind the dog and would not have much light hitting it. Both wings have equal value as they are now. I'd take a layer above your bat wings, create a clipping mask, and see if you can set the mode to multiply and and airbrush in some shadows. (or just mess with the curves to darken it)

But overall it's very good! Good pose and wing choice that mesh well together.

 

The job is pretty good, I'd give it a 10. Not bad!

 

same here, pretty good

 

Its nice...............

 

i'd give it a 7/8 the white background just throws itoff w/ the pic of the treats in the background...(its treats correct?)

 

7 out of 10. The wing really doesn't match with the tone of the overall picture.

 

7/10. The dogs hair needs better extraction and the colors need some touch. Besides that, it's good

 

Its kinda cute but still need some improvements. i will give you 7/10

 

Awww... that is so cute!

I think its a 9. I would have like to see the front paws of the terrier still on the manip.

 

Even if there is a scary "Robin the Bat Terrier"! The site looks cute for me.

8/10

 

i would give it an 8.. .these dogs are insanely cute.. .and the design is good.. .so good luck.. .

 

it is decent, give it a 7. Could have be slightly better though

 

7/10. The dog is so cute, but the bottom image of the dog seem has been erased..maybe better..add white basket though

 

6/10 , sorry if that sounds harsh.

 

I think about an 8, It looks a little too cartoonish to me

 

I would like to give you 8/10.

 

Pretty good .....
I'd give it 10/10 for the morphing and 8/10 for the lighting

 

Does the dog still has a blue leash on his chest????
If is true, then i wouldn't rate it too high....

 

nice one dude 8/10