Here are the stats: 1) Keyword domain ( www.carpetcleaninglongislandny.com ) doesnt show up within the top 100 results for the keyword targeted but for other phrases it's on the 2nd page. Note that we have been doing SEO on this domain for over 4 months. It has a lot of the same text content as their 2 year old domain. 2) 2 year old domain ( pcs-easternli.com ) rank 93 for keyword. Should I just redirect the pcs-easternli.com to carpetcleaninglongislandny.com or vice versa?
No offense but both domains look bad in my eyes. Don't you think a brandable domains would be a better idea in this case? The way I see it you have nothing to lose in this case. Both domains are not ranking high in the search engines. I would consider registration of a new domain, otherwise just use www.carpetcleaninglongislandny.com