Sour Grapes alert..... do a search for 'Cigars' 'Arturo Fuente' Thompson Cigar is the offender. They are out there on DOZENS of high volume cigar terms. Blatant cloaked pages. I've turned these guys in to Google more times than I can count. These pages have been there for YEARS. I understand from a programatic viewpoint, these might be hard to detect. But when it is repeatedly pointed out...... Google doesn't seem to have any problems keeping my sites buried in the serps depsite me following their guidelines to a tee.
Not doorway page; cloaking. Showing the search engines one one page yet driving searchers to another. The Google bot doesn't get forwarded like you do.
I was searching less competitive poker terms the other day and I kept getting forwarded to the actual poker rooms from obscure domains on page 1 in Google serps.