I hope this to be a very interactive and useful thread. Concerning SEO as well as keeping in mind general business practices such as marketing, what would you see more beneficial? The NAME of a domain, the # of Characters of a domain or the age of the domain. Here is the Background: 1) A business is going online and wants to capture a broader market. 2) Business will be marketing through organic search, paid search, mailers in the mail, billboards and radio ads. 3) It is in a highly competitive market. 4) The organization name is four words with a roughly character count of 30 characters. (example: Orangatang Lucys Tooth Paste) Here are the options: 1) The organization has a domain name that takes the first two words as an acronym and then spells out the last two words of the organization name. This is very description of what the organization does. (Example: oltoothpaste.com). In the example the domain name says toothpaste in it which is descriptive of what the organization does. Domain name registration is less than 1 year old. 2) The organization has a four letter acronym domain registered that is 10 years old. (Example: oltp.com) What would you do? I hope that this gives some great information to ponder about. The organization, due to its long name, intends to promote the acronym saying of the name, although the acronym four letters doesn't line up with any search term they offer since it seems like random letters. What would you do taking into account SEO and general business practices such as marketing? POLL ADDED
It depends on so many factors but the use of the four words and even hyphenated should be taken into consideration especially if they are a search phrase. If you want to be smart you could use the acronyom and four words as sites in unison working together. WP is good for doing such things
Strictly for SEO, the longer exact match would be better. But, for your customers, a shorter, more memorable domain is better. Depends on how you want to market it.
Just FYI, forum readers and posters in this day and age tend to look for short, right-to-the-point posts. Anything longer —> bye, bye.