Hi Guys, After India's defeat against Aussies and WI in the T20 world cup, what are your comments on MSD's captaincy?? Do you think the fault is with the team selection? Do you think it was a bad decision by Dhoni to choose fielding against WI? Again playing R. Jadeja who was so badly hit against Aussies??? .......the comments goes on... what do you think was the reason for India's defeat...
i would say its because of Dhoni's arrogant attitude we lost.. He came down with the same team to prove his critics that he can win with the same team...Every one commented that he should pick one more pace bowler..and in spite of Jadeja being thrashed against Aussies he took him and gave the ball, and that proved very costly for India.
Captaincy is good and there is no doubt about it. Thing is that we've 8 TOP batsmen but all guys are getting failed again and again. Even they didn't able to reach 2 figures. So that's the reason according to me. So captaincy is not involved in it at all..
I believe that is Captaincy, is well-deserved and he does a good job. Wells could do all the things that he does?
Even I agree that Dhoni has a attitude problem.. that's the reason he came up with the same team that lost against Aussies..because he was criticized of not having 1 more pace bowler. He wanted to prove that he was correct, so he came down with the same team again. Dhoni said before the world cup that our team is perfectly balanced even without Sehwag. But that's not true, Indian batting line up is never perfect without Sehwag and Sachin. Moreover Robin Uthapa has done so well in IPL that he should have been given a chance. For me Uthapa is a better batsmen that M. Vijay in these pitches.
I like MSD captaincy very much, but some errors will happen here and there as you said about R. Jadeja.
I think this guy fears taking risks...... If u want to be the bets in the world, you got to take some calculated risks... He should have played vinay kumar in the Australian match itself. Just because its a bouncy pitch and also the ground was very small... since India had a lot of spinning options with yusuf,yuvi,rohit and raina..... Jadeja could have easily given way for vinay kumar...
India got a golden chance to make it to the semis, but the middle order batting failed to make a good score at the end. Even though we got a good start we could'nt convert it into a good total. MS Dhoni's 23 of 19 balls was a failure.
I think his captaincy is good but due to IPL they are not p erforming well and I think money is another matter too.
Dhoni is d best captain indian team ever had but he is not a super hero to win all the matches and at the same time he handles any situation very fine with his experiments and most of the time it works and very few times it doesnt work. cricket is not a one man show its a team effort and the pressure will only be on the captain who will end up getting bashed for the losses. stop making weird comments about dhoni i blv after sachin dhoni is one of indias biggest asset.
I think there is no fault in Dhoni's Captaincy! it is performance of overall Team which made Dhoni responsible for this! Although He can manage the team cant play for next 10 players in the team
No one can deny that Dhoni is arrogant...and he always thinks what he does is perfectly correct.. Even though before the world cup he did not utter anything about the IPL when asked..but after the defeat he takes a flip and blames IPL's overnight parties and late matches. check out this below link.. http://t20wc.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/5923392.cms
IPL rains money on them. they don't have enough reason/motivation to perform in the international cricket. this is my not-so-humble view