Hey, Been running this site for a while now, 3500 members and lots of features. Over 4,000 uniques a day and lots of active users who upload games every few hours. http://mostplays.com/ Thanks -Dan
You got some good pages in there. Many pr3 inner pages and 30000+ indexed ones. This is important. But the price is always negotiable. There is no fixed value. The only number you can extract without setting a auction is by multiplying the "money you actually make (roughly) per month" as Gallito said.
According to cubestat.com which takes information on traffic flow and a ton of other resources states the value at ..... HOLY SHIT cubestat.com/www.mostplays.com $17,000 +++ rep me then help me with my website pllzzz lol It says you made this site mid last year wow talk about doing things right! and apparently this is the look it started with lol - web.archive.org/web/20070703120202/http://mostplays.com/
You dont have any Ads in your site, well most of the website value checker they show hypes but the price depends on the traffic you receive and income you generate through it per month. As you mentioned you have 4000 uniques a day your earning should also be reasonable to get good pricing. If you earn $10+ from ads daily then it is sure worth $1500+ Good Luck