For the first one 3/10 Second one 5/10 I'd suggest you making a logo for your site make a sorta logo as in permanent logo with HJ which resembles the site, and put that logo and along with text prolly you can use the second logo's text.. so it'll look more attractive yet professional
Revision looks much better. Not bad for a first try. What I would say to improve it even more would be to contrast the unlimited more. You have two similar, fat, bolded, similar styled fonts. It makes it where every thing is screaming. You need to play down the unlimited. maybe make it solid color, not bolded and smaller. I think
I'll try to make it more gold. I'll post here if I have finished revising it. Yeah. I would just put it into a header for the site. Thanks for the comment. Not bad for my first try though.
I don't think It's bad for a first attempt at a logo. Certainly not the worst I've seen. I like the "Henshin Justice" part with the two blues. I don't think it worked with the blue/black gradient, just made it look dirty. I have to say though I think the "unlimited" part lets it down alot. 5/10
Although the second one is a bit better, "unlimited" is very hard on the eyes. A logo should be easy to read, not hard. Everything about it, the stripes, the colour, the tacky drop shadow and even the font make it look poor. Keep it simple and easy to read.
it's very simple, and not great to look at, you could use something my eye pealing for others that will stand out... not too sure what your site is about but try and incorporate that into it. including mixing different colours to bring out a more happy feeling. Rate: 2/10 (i rate quite strict.)
5/10 - Put the logo on the forum then we'll see how it looks But even if it's on the forum, highest i'll rate is like 6