So I submited my sites and whatnot, and they sent me an e-mail saying that couldn't verify it was me (I guess because I have whois privacy?) Idk, but I sent him screen shots of c-panel and the domains, and I sent him screen shots of my receipts. He sent me an e-mail back saying "apologize for not specifying our requirements beforehand. The screenshots you sent are great, but none show a link between your name and the domain name." Any idea what I should send him a screen shot of?
Put a page on your domain with your application info (or your correspondence), and then email that page to them. That will at least prove that you have control of the site.