For example.. let's say i had the keyword: computer repair. Just the broad keyword, no city added. I go onto google adwords ad preview and set my city to New York. I am on page 1 on the search engine for : computer repair However, I then change my city from New York to Manhattan. Now I am not on page 1. Why is this? There are a bunch of cities I am on page 1 for the broad keyword, but also a lot of cities where I'm not on page 1.
You web rankings are influenced by Geographic locations. With your current Google webmaster tools setting, Google is considering your website suitable for a specific geographic location. Since, now you are targeting Manhattan you probably will gain rankings gradually. You rankings also depends on your competitors efforts.Â