I see. So it's not all workers. You're predominantly concerned with low skill, low education, low productivity workers. Why can't they move? Start their own businesses? Change occupations? Why should we reward and coddle people who don't increase their skills, and don't increase their productivity? Why should the rest of us pay their way? Thank you for making my point. We're talking about the least educated, least productive and least skilled. Sounds like an incentive to be ambitious, do well in school and continue upgrading. Socialized government policy says, "It's ok to not improve or compete, we will protect your job even if you don't produce." I wouldn't use the word force. The employee has a choice. As do I. I'm in business to make a profit, not to accommodate people's personal schedules. If I can find someone to replace the worker (the more skilled and productive they are, the harder this will be) and work my hours, then I should hire them because it makes me competitive and allows me to stay in business. If I can't (scarce labor) then I wouldn't be wise to lose the existing worker. If the supply of labor is too great, then you need people to die or more places to work. Oh wait, government red tape and regulation is so thick, the businesses have all moved to Asia. And by punishing the remaining ones, we'll make sure that the only ones who can survive are the mega corps, that mass employs legions of the underclass. This is not what I want, but this is what is coming if government keeps meddling. The market trends towards equilibrium. It wants to allocate resources efficiently, and an excess of unemployed labor is not efficient. You're short jobs. But taxes and regulation drive jobs to foreign markets, while your high standard of living and wages attract low skill foreign workers to the UK. It's an ugly time. But only the competitive will survive. Artificial government standards will not last. Fair enough.
Firstly because the economy couldn't sustain it, if the workforce followed your advice and all went out to start a business tomorrow, the economy would collapse. Secondly, you're asking the wrong person, I've never worked for someone else because I don't want to, but it just so happens that the majority of the population in every country are working uncompetitive jobs. Definitely, but not everyone can be what they want, no matter how ambitious they are. There will always be someone needed to flip burgers or scan food products. No, taxes and regulation are not the main factor driving jobs to Asia, it's money. If you can pay someone $6/day in Asia, or $120/day in the UK, for the same jobs and very little difference in product and logistics, it's going to be Asia everytime. We (in the UK) cannot possibly live on $6/day, even if it was legal to pay that low with no government interference and no tax. The market will adapt, as we are seeing, our factories and mining industries are gone, but our financial sector is thriving. There's no point in competing on price with Asia.
They all already are in business as labor contractors. We're all involved in trade, whether we own the name above the door or not. Right. Good entry level or late life jobs for people. It doesn't have to be a career occupation. Do you understand why it is so expensive to live in the UK? You're paying for the welfare state, the warfare state, taxes, entitlements, pensions, education and who knows what. Not beating up the UK, it's the same in all modern democracies. As I told you, the cost of regulation and regulatory compliance gets pushed onto the consumer. That's why you have to make $X per hour or day. Because the cost of doing business is so high. I keep pointing to the internet, on the internet's premier english language webmaster forum, that the internet is a super example of a free market. There are no shortages of jobs or opportunities. People thrive and survive on their merit, not their looks, religion or race. There are no minimum blogger wages, or forum labor standards. We don't subsidize the bad internet workers, and the best ones have not taken over the "world" (net) with their wealth and expertise. Don't think the financial industry in the UK will last. The Asians are coming for that one next, and only the smart, the strong and the ambitious will survive.
Piqued by Countryboy's post, I was surprised to see just how much statutory law, as opposed to precedent case law, was relied upon in key constitutional questions: http://www.llrx.com/features/uk.htm#Background%20&%20Constitution (emphasis mine). I'm intrigued by this, as my understanding is obviously outdated. Like you, Wisdom, it was my previous understanding that British law rested almost exclusively on stare decisis, while on the continent, following not in small measure on the ideas established by Napoleon's reforms, cases are argued and decided upon almost exclusively by reference to civil statutes - many of which conflict and must be adjudicated by a justice weighing the relative applicability and merit of the statutes being argued.
Do you think Asia is going to stay in the stone age? They're living standards are increasing at a rate never seen before, their state funded education is getting better and better, it won't be long until they're around the same level as us.
Well, we are forever learning. The great ancient Chinese philosopher Confucius once said that in any group of 3 person, there is definitely one you can learn something from. There are many thousands of triplets here . A great deal of knowledge which the other members have unselfishly provided us.
If you look at Asians living in the West, you're at soonest talking about a multi-generational thing. Will there be a "West" left to compete with? I think you're missing the point. Our standards are going to drop a lot faster than theirs will rise. Despite the # of laws the government writes, regulations it enforces, I have yet to see a law that can overcome the forces of nature.
Yep, agreed, Wisdom. From my experience, with very few exceptions, this is an extraordinary place for us to come together in good faith, globally, and learn new perspectives. Kudos, and thanks, to Shawn for providing the space, and for the mods for putting up with it.