$70 Contest For Football (Soccer) Forum Logo/Banner

Leading entries for logo:
*********************
RNHalawi.com ( if he adds that magic touch )


NightVisioN ( if he makes those changes )


nicogarcia ( has pushed it as far as it can go in terms of changes )


Leading entry for banner
*******************
coolwanz

 

@Daveyboy:No actually I like Cesc to be facing that way, kind of gives the banner two halves, the logo half and the rest half ( just the way it plays in my mind )

 

Thank you for your invitation for me to join this contest.

Feedback from my entry is appreciated. Remember, color can be changed if you don't like it.

 

Yeah fair enough haha, I always just hate when logos and stuff are flipped

it's really a great banner though mate!

 

And a glossy version.

 

Hi XFactorLogo,

Thanks for the effort mate. Unfortunately, the entry is not up there with the rest of the best entries.

J

 

Hi,

any feedback I could to do make it better?

 

I notice you have been 'patrolling' the forums and having a go at people for vectorizing copyrighted stuff - but you did the same for the footballers here did you not?

 

@XFactorLogo: Fair enough, sorry mate, here goes:

I don't like the footballer to be black, and he is too big for the rest of the text... perhaps you could make him smaller and fit in with the rest of logo.

The box is too plain, perhaps could be broken apart with a badge... although there are two other badge entries so it would be hard to make something new and different.

The font I like but I dont like the shadow behind it.

Perhaps this will help: I haven't seen any entries where the Badge is the center of attention like at http://www.fflcommish.com/... the badge makes up the logo.

J

 

Nice effort everyone.

@Geronimo
About the 3 best logos, I trully dislike RN's work, it seems empty, it doesnt have border, its not up to the other 2 logo's level.
About Nightvision's and Nigocarcia's logos I think both are pretty good, but I will give nicogarcia my vote for a few reasons:

NightV its not as easy to read. Since its a long name IFYOUTYPEALLTOGETHER it gets harder to read.
Readability point for Nicogarcia.

NightV's could be a little bit more "web 2.0" because the gradients and stuff but you cant apply it in a tshirt or anything like that because it has way to many colors.

Im not sure if I like Badges as logos, badges turns to be very specific.

Also you will struggle resizing NightV's logo.

About Coolwanz banner.
He used to do more classy things I think its to overloaded, try something more simplistic with better taste.

 

Ah, before I saw your feedback I already made another one. I'll see what I can do momentarily

 

Was that the design police I heard whizz by??

 

Here was the one I made before I read your feedback. I'm making one with your feedback right now.

 

Well, I might know a little bit more about design than you.

You might not have 2 International awards. I DO
You might not have gave more than 14 conferences in Paris, Mexico, London, Sydney, NY, Chicago, LA, Buenos Aires and Sao Paulo about Graphic Design, Brand Identity and Design Trends and more. Well, I DID

I have my reasons.

Take care

 

I am going to sleep, it's 3am here in Europe. I will be back to post more feedback in about 6 hours.

Cheers and thanks for the effort everyone.

John

 

Congrats, do share with us your work

In the mean time, i'm going back to work on my 5 figure proposal for a real estate company

Edit : Saw your portfolio; nice work, of course. Well done.

We just usually reserve detailed feedback for the contest holder. Bit less pretentious that's all.

 

Where did the pic in your logo come from?

----EDIT----

Sorry, missed Davey already asked this.

 

Ive asked someone in another contest to clearify for me, but Im pretty sure recreating a photo in vector artwork is not copyright infringment. Im talking about the people using acuall photos. Not saying you cant do it, Im just sick of seeing people get sued for it.

 

OK, John, here's a couple from me.








Hope you like! Feedback appreciated.