50$ Logo Contest for Band Website

Hi Guys,

Sorry for coming back to you so late, but I was in bed with a pretty nasty cold. Here are the comments from the band:


"First of all, thank you very much for your efforts.

And here are the honest and open comments of the band members:

animator: "sorry,to be honest, but this is nothing special or unique or creative at all"


currenz: "quite nice, but looks like the logo of a local cover band. Do not need so many instruments in the LOGO - should look more unique and special"

skyblue webteam:

"quite nice, but looks like the logo of a local cover band. do not need so many instruments in the LOGO - should look more special and more unique"

Sandeepramje: " quite nice, but too many pics. if there an image of us, then it would be better if it was something like an abstract drawing or a caricature or something like that"

to luvlee:" too heavy metal and hardrock like, too serious. does not fit to us that much. We play Thai rock and pop music, and do not take ourselves too serious either..., some of us did not like that guitar either. So finally it should be something completely different than this"

nine: "sorry, but nothing special or unique at all...."

Hope for your understanding for the frank comments. Thanks."

Seems they have pretty high expectations. I hope you can fullfill them. As I was sick for 2 days we will extend the deadline until 24.01.07.

BizLord

 

thanks for the feedback...i hope to submit more design later today.......

 

No feedback at post #19?

Thank you

 

Feedback for #20?

I'll be back with more entries.

 

my another try....



hope u like it...feedback appreciated..

 

Hi Guys,

Sorry but I do not have any comments for #19 and #20 from the band yet.

Comment for "Sandeepramje":

"Nice banner! We particularly like the letters of SOMANGO and the nice yellow-black background.

We are quite interested in it, but we have still some things to suggest:

- take the pic of us out
- put the lettering in the middle and this background, which you now have on the right side (next to our pic), should be perhaps all over
- The Latin lettering should be maybe a little bit wider (stretched horizontally a bit) and maybe also a bit larger
- the Thai letters should be a bit smaller and they should be below the Latin letters
- please no apostrophies at the Thai letters

Thanks very much for your efforts."

BizLord

 

thanks for the feedback, i will do the same as you needed....thanks

 

heres the revised submission.....

1.

2.

feedback much appreciated...

thanks,
Sandeep

 

Ok, here is mine:


And the preview:


Hope you guys will like it.

 

Ok Guys, sorry for taking so long to give feedback but the bandleader always has to wait to show the designs to the band members. We will extend the deadline for 3 more days, this should be sufficient to be able to find a winner.

Here the new comments:

istvan und loserXP: sorry for the delay.
# 19 and 20: "thanks for your tries, but we are not likely to take one of these, because we much more tend to take that one of another bidder, which we are quite interested in.
# 19: nice try, but not really what we want.sorry."
# 20: sorry, frankly:not special at all. not that much creative.

sandee P: #28 " could you please try to make the same effects on the thai lettering as you have on the latin lettering? and, as said before, try to take the pic of us out or make it not that clear or more cartoon like (for ex.: only seeing the contours or outlines of us). Maybe make two tries to compare: for one try " take the four guys out" and for another try "leave them, but make them more like a cartoon and/or show only the outlines/contours/silhouttes of them. And then we would like to compare. Thank you.

Luvlee: Nice try. However, the latin lettering should be a bit clearer, more easy to read. Beside that, I have to ask the band members about this try.

# 17: interesting background, but the lettering is nothing special at all and too small. beside that, i have to ask the other band members for further comments. thanks you.

BizLord

 

heres my updated entry...

1.

2.

3.

continue....

 

heres more

4.

feedback appreciated

 

Hi Guys,

Sorry for the delay. We appoint Sandee P. as the winner for this bidding. Money will be sent shortly!

BizLord

 

thanks...i get back to you shortly...