Hi Everyone, I just got back from dinner and I am really thankful to you all who have submitted an entry.. For those who wants to submit, don't worry I will wait until the closing date (5 September) before picking a design as I am excited to see the design and creativity that you guys bring and for that thank you once again Since there are quite a lot of entries, I am going to try give a quick comments on each. If you want more feedback feel free to let me know and I will try my best to explain further.. (but once again, please don't do anything now as I don't want to waste your time making changes incase I don't pick your design as I really appreciate the hard work you put through.. I will pick the winner on 5 September) katesrobyn: I like your concept. I want to know why you choose the dotted fonts. I find the palm trees distracting as it covers the text so I would remove them. I would make the text 'Rainbow' in one color as at the moment it's a bit too colorful (I think the logo looks much better on black at the moment because text is too colorful on white). The roof shape looks like umbrella, I think maybe it will look better if it's a Rainbow shape instead and you can introduce the Rainbow color on the roof instead of the text? hemp: thank you for the PM, I replied to you on the PM already Belz314, gipanuhotko & Dakouten: thank you for the entry.. I thought I combine the feedback as the three of you have a similar concept having the hut with the rainbow over it. I find the concept a bit too straight forward (I am looking for more unusual interpretation) But illustration wise Belz314, nice illustration but I find yours a bit too iconic for a logo (I think your style will look great as icons / buttons instead), gipanuhotko nice illustration and Dakouten also nice illustration thou I am worried the small details will get lost when the logo is resized quite small. tickey: your entry is the one I love the best so far..! I love the interpretation, very unusual but effective. Love the colors. The logo works when resized big / small. If there is something different I want to see is just how the logo will look with a couple of different fonts (I like the fonts you have at the moment but would like to see it on other fonts that are not as condensed). And also I'll be interested to see how the logo look in a horizontal version in addition to the stack version that you currently have so they can be used across different deliverables.
Hi twistedpiston, Thank you for your entry.. I think you have a very nice illustration skill, though I am after a more unusual concept than just a rainbow with a hut. You have a very nice composition skill, the image and the text interacts really well together.. Also I am afraid the details of the illustration will get lost when the logo is resized small (especially worried about the fine bamboo hut color against the yellow color of the rainbow). Please don't worry about making any changes now as I will select a winner on the closing date and I don't want to waste your time incase I am choosing other entry.
Hi everyone, just had time to log in for a bit.. Wow.. some really good new entries..! I will have a think and let you know the feedback.
sorry I only have time for one feedback for now, I'll start from the top one first. I'll be back for more.. jamess: thank you for your entry I like your illustration and how you portray the hut illustration (having the rainbow inside the hut) though I find there is quite a lot of going on in the same time. Things are too colorful put together with the hut, orange sun and the grass and the red text over the green grass that my eyes got a bit confused at first (everything screams at me tad bit much). I am not sure about having the sun, but it's growing on me. Though I definitely don't like the grass as it makes it a bit too much.
Hi all, some more feedbacks. Took me a while to think as there are some really high quality design works. I am waiting til tomorrow before closing the competition, but it will be a tough one to pick: tickey: I like no 1 and 3 a lot! No 3 caught my attention at the start though I like no 1 because the font thickness almost matches the brush stroke thickness so they look like they belong together more I am leaning towards 1 at the moment. nice design work. writetoday: thank you for the revision, though I am looking for something more than just having a literal interpretation of having a hut with a rainbow. And I really like the font you had previously as it looked really funky, fun, clean and professional. This script font looks fun but I feel it's lacking the professional feeling to it. katesrobyn: I like the new version that you do! Only couple of thing: 1) I think the image looks more like a house than a hut. 2) not sure about the RH inside as I don't really want to have reference as RH. Like everything else! nice design work. MantisArt: thank you for your entry. I like the top one with the shadow below the 'H' better. thank you it looks good. nice design work. jamess: thank you for the revision. I like it much better nice design work.
Hi everyone, Just want to let you know that the competition is closing soon. It will be the 6th September in few hours. katesrobyn, I am waiting for your entry still. I will be waiting for the next 5 hours, then I will pick the winner..
Competition is now closed. The winner is tickey. Thank you everyone for participating, it has been a pleasure to see some really nice design works.. I will contact the winner by PM to finalize the transaction.
Payment received, files sent. Even it was your first contest, but you managed it very well. Regards Tanmay