Okay, time for some feedback. First off let me say WOW! There’s some really nice work here. It’s going to be hard to choose a winner, but that’s a good problem. I’d like everyone to read the entire feedback not just the part with your name. This will give you more idea of what we’re looking for. In General: We kinda like the bubbly letters like the “S.I.†here: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com//. Also I’d like to have the .com at the end of the fan pit. Technically our biz is registered under thefanpit.com so I’d like to keep the .com on there. Feel free to try it vertically and horizontal. As for the “The Fan Pit†You can use it in any way you want and if we want it changed we’ll let you know (example: TheFanPit.com, The Fan Pit.com, TheFANPIT.com, etc.). Ariestoteles: First one to the plate! Not exactly what we were going for. We kinda want more of the mob of fans feel, with a hint of all sports, all fans coming together. Thanks for your try. I hope you try again! Scarlet Edition: for some reason I could see your design before but now my work computer is giving me the dreaded X. I’ll try and view it again with my home computer and let you know. Cyberspirits: You’re getting more of the idea, but it’s not quite what I’m looking for. It’s almost too much going on and the people still look a bit too photoshop’d. Sniip3r: This was our hands down favorite as of yesterday. That being said we haven’t looked at or discussed anything after yours. We had a few things we’d like you to adjust. We wanted to see if you could do something with a little less field and some more fan shots. We really like the field but just a little less. Also could you try a more bubbly font. See what you can come up with. All in all, VERY nice job! Also: Is that Joey Porter? Mac Crazy: I like your concept. Unfortunately I just think there are a couple that are better. Maybe a different type of font? It kinda looks holloweenish. It’s hard to give you good feedback because I really do like it, just not as much as some others. DaveyBoy: I personally like the first one the best. Again, I haven’t had a chance to discuss this with my partners yet. Pretty nice design. I’ll let you know what my people say later. bmR89: Sorry, you’re another one that my computer won’t show. All I see is the little red X. I’ll try again at home and get back to you. Supernoobice: I’m glad you PM’d me because I really like this. This design I haven’t discussed with my people yet so everything I’m telling you is only my opinion. So it could change. Having said that I really like this. The fields in the letters really looks nice! I would take out the soccer, fans, and basketball subtitles. I would change the football player on the left to a baseball or basketball player. Then make two of those boxes pics of fans. But use more crazy pics of fans. The one’s you have in the middle are a bit too preppy. We want FANATIC!! Then I would fill the middle box with either baseball or basketball depending on which you used on the left. So on the banner you would have baseball, basketball and football. With lots of fans between each of them. Does that make sense? And please add the .com. If you want you can try a hockey rink in that. PM me if you have any questions. Also: If you want to get brownie points with the other judges they like the Dallas Cowboys, SanFran 49ers, SF Giants, LA Lakers, Cleveland Browns, Cavs, Indians. Just so you know. But if you find killer pics of any other teams please use them.
Okay now I can see them???? This is weird, but hey we got it. Scarlet Edition: I liked yours but I think some others are a little better. I really like the crispness of the pic. It looks really clean and professional. The problem is it doesn’t really send our message like some of the others. bmR89: Good job! I’d probably like to see a different field other than soccer. I know a lot of people on here are from countries where soccer is “the sport†but unfortunately it’s not here. Although I’d like to have soccer included eventually it’s probably going to be one of the last added because it’s one we’re least familiar with. I’ll have to discuss with my partners for more feedback. Thanks!!
Hey Sniip, could you make the fans in the back colored? Also maybe the fans overlaping the field in color? Just like to see how it looks.
Wow, you're fast!! Very nice! I'll be discussing these with my people tonight. They might want to see a different font. We'll see. I'll update you by tomorrow morning at the latest.
Wow!!! another great contest here.... thankyou for your feedback, will upload edited version from my 'test the water' version..
Yeah, it's safe to say I won't be exercising my "no winner" option. These are looking great. It's gonna be tough. Can't wait to hear what my partners think!
Is it hard to chage it to 800 x 200 or 250? If it is then don't worry about it but if it's easy I'd like to see it.