$125 Logo Contenst

Thanks for the feedback, here's the revision:



with gradients:

 

My 2nd Logo proposal:

 

No actually I'm not, I've received Reputation Points from some users who liked the design.
thanks for the offending feedback.

 

here is my design .. feedback please



and

 

Ok, apparently my images aren't showing up ???

 

I might enter this later,

Thanks.

 

Katesrobyn - That last once is really nice. Might look better with wearhouse underneath the logo instead of above and a more pastel like shade of green.
Belablack - I really like the font and overall graphic but the colors are off
Itrungs - That's to bland, the bottom one is a step in the right direction, i like the image inside the O, but the colors are off and its still a bit bland

Anidesign and Addictedtofate have the clean look and color scheme I like.

For everyone else and their problems with my feedback, its called constructive criticism. Really if your submitting work like that at real job I wouldn't expect you to keep it for long. Better to be honest with you then massage your ego.

 

my entry
feedback(negative or positive) appreciated..

 

Feedback appreciated.

 

here is another design

 

The thing is none of these guys work for you and they don't owe you anything so your argument is flawed. It's called courtesy. You don't like some of their work that is your call. But since they spent their unpaid time for something that will benefit you, there is a polite way of saying why you don't like their submissions. And just like with your last contest for the same logo you completely disregarded their work. With your "honest" attitude I wouldn't hire you either. Anyway, good luck with your contest.

 

That's not constructive criticism, you didn't offer anything to improve on.

 

may I join???



for $125.. or PM me for negotiation...

 

man you like to troll these forums huh

 

Proteindude actually has a reputation here for making decent contests and providing amazing feedback.

 

Wow. This contest is quite amusing.

 

You can learn quite a bit from Proteindude; he is deserving of imitation because of his excellence as a contest holder.

 

I see you took the time to reply to my post. However, since my post you also received two more entries. Don't you think it would be more appropriate to reply to those two entries you received before you reply to me Besides I was also offering what YOU may call "constructive criticism". Look at it this way: with every comment you get from me you also get a bump. Heck, I could even get an infraction for helping you get a bump.

BTW, the reason I was on this thread is because I noticed some of the guys whose style I really like were posting here so was looking forward to seeing their work. But you can rest assured I won't be posting AT ALL on this thread anymore because once again, I think you should bother to reply to those who are entering your contest not to me