Fireworks VS Photoshop

oOo - I will leave it up to the posters, but I want to see who wins between FW and Photoshop, this is a CS3 only thing, so no studio 8 stuff allowed.

I VOTE FIREWORKS!!!



FIREWORKS FTW!

Vote and post though, so i can keep tabs on who is teh winner of teh place

 

I like Fireworks. It's a nice clear lay-out, where everything is easy to the eye. I vote... Fireworks.

 

Fireworks is best for Web IMO. But for a all around work horse, you can't beat CS3 PS. I must say that I am using the Adobe Fireworks more and more then my dear Photoshop.

 

Fireworks works best for web design and it's contents but just like quizak said "But for a all around work horse, you can't beat CS3 PS". I am a designer myself and I'm doing different kinds of design solution and I often use photoshop than fireworks.

 

this 2 that you said is 2 software that are 100% difference FireWorks is only designed for web ,you never can paint with fireworks as photoshop and you never can make a button with photoshop as FW

 

I like both of them together...I use them both on several of my templates and it makes life a lot easier.

 

I use fireworks only for the web, photoshop for the web and design, so...

 

I think you need both these days but if I HAD to have one I would definitely go for Fireworks

 

Fireworks is somewhat less advanced and generally focused for the web as most of you have already pointed out. One advantage of fireworks is that it has traditionally always had better compression for jpegs than photoshop. Although now with both in cs3 versions, i haven't come around to testing that theory. And yet, for everything else - its photoshop!

 

Photoshop CS3 ftw, I always use it, wether it's designing/printdesign/webdesign, I always use it

 

wow is this even a competition? I've used both, but I find Photoshop a LOT easier to use. Fireworks just isn't as user-friendly as I'd like it to be.

 

Mostly photoshop,
but I will use fireworks for certain applications as well.
In fact Adobe illustrator, Photo ulead are very useful as well.

 

I use fireworks. It's more user friendly

 

I'm a photoshoper through and through, never even tried fireworks.

 

When i comes to Web Design...

Fireworks in unbeatable.

And when i comes to Print and Retouching etc...

Photoshop is the tool!

 

I use both, Photoshop is a bit heavy than fireworks so i use firework when i just want to edit something simple and for complex design photoshop come to hte rescue.

 

I use Photoshop for more complicated graphics and mostly using it for more effects.

 

i'd say it's like this: Fireworks for beginners because it's easier to use from my point of view. and Photoshop for those that already know more about graphics and how to use it's numerous features.

 

Both but photoshop is alot better to customize etc.

 

photoshop all the way.... I used fireworks several times and didn't care for it