Is reply necessary for itrader ??

I have made a reply on this thread/post http://forums.digitalpoint.com/showthread.php?p=2134369#post2134369 yesterday.

I just replied " PM sent with my 6 sites offer , please consider" something like this only.

I got an infarction for it too now. and the post was deleted.
( If my post is deleted then why not those other similar posts ??)

I have no oppose for getting infarction for that post but I want to ask ::

Whether it's necessary to post a reply in B/S/T threads to share itrader?

I know we would have worked in PM communication only but I posted for sharing itrader also.

If we cannot share itrader without replying a thread - then I please request you to undelete my post and infarction too.

 

Yes. It is necessary to participate in a deal thread to qualify for an iTrader. Perhaps a better option there is to first PM the member who made a thread to ask him for details then post something after the transactions took place. This can also prevent iTrader abuse.

 

1. No it is not necessary to post in thread to post iTrader. Requirement is to have been participant of deal discussed in thread.

 

Yep. i totally agree with you.
Putting a url is just to make sure you are really the buyer.

 

I'm afraid you're wrong. You need to post in a thread so that you can qualify for an iTrader. You can not just give an iTrader if transaction was through PM. So, you need to post in the thread that you are submitting a feedback for.

 

My understanding is different that yours.

I went to look something up and came across this:
http://forums.digitalpoint.com/showthread.php?t=189662

Where it looks like we are both consistent in our opinions at least!

 

There are two opinions here..
Can mod or admin - please answer the question ?
If reply is necessary - Then what we can post so that not to get an infarction ?

 

reply is not necessary. Shawn has posted once that an itrader can be given even without posting in the thread provided the deal has been made through the thread itself. I'l try finding the post if I can

 

I am still waiting to know :

Is reply necessary in the BST threads ??
If yes, what kind of reply can we make so that not to get infarction ??

If no, can we deal in PM and then share itrader ?

 

AFAIK, there needs to be a thread as a reference URL, but you do not need to post that you did the deal.