There's the obvious adsense but what else can I do? I don't want to do Zango because of the spyware/adware thing and typical ads don't get good CTR at all since the traffic is untargeted.
That is really tough. Untargeted? Wow....I'm sitting here trying to come up with some ideas for you and I'm drawing a blank. There's got to be SOME reason they are going to your site. You stats don't tell you ANYTHING?
RevenueDirect maybe? I'm not sure why the traffic would be untargeted unless you are buying visitors from an expired domain traffic broker. Those don't convert whatsoever.
Adbrite for now until you find something else that works.... Check out my sig link...adbrite is there and a couple others you might wanna check out.
Incentive Offers is the way. Say you can direct the visitors to a page which says "You get a $50 Visa card if you complete the following offers". Then promote incentive offers there. Make sure the commissions make up to 100$ so that you could give the visa card.
If you have untargeted traffic then you better use combination of ppc and ppm programs. ppc: adsense, adbrite, bidvertiser (see my signature link #1),... ppm: paypopup, adbrite, clicksor, tribalfusion,..
I'd go with any sort of impression type program so you don't have to worry about getting your traffic to click on ads.
Thanks for all the ideas everyone. For those who want to know, the traffic is from social bookmarking sites (digg and SU) so I'm just submitting different things. I don't think CPAlead would work well since most people would just end up downvoting my submits on networks because of it. I've heard CPI/CPM isn't too great now a days but I could give it a try. Another option would be blackhat.